South Region
#9 Miami Hurricanes over #37 Mississippi Valley State Delta Devils - Where have the Delta Devils succeeded where their demonic brethren have failed? Their apparent ability to shoot fire at people. But that fire does precious little against driving storms and 100+ mile per hour winds.
#5 Furman Paladins over #20 Vanderbilt Commodores - I feel like I don’t have to explain this, but as a reminder a Paladin is a knight on a horse and a Commodore is a dude with a sword inspired by a business magnate.
#19 UAB Blazers over #6 Tennessee Volunteers - “Blaze the Mascot Dragon / Reps UAB / And barbecued the Volunteer from a state called Tennessee”
#31 Longwood Lancers over #10 North Carolina Tar Heels - Not a great couple of games for human mascots that also represent their respective state’s nickname.
East Region
#34 Canisius Golden Griffins over #24 Army Black Knights - This one is a toss-up. I found a website that had some medieval art depicting encounters between Knights and Griffins. Obviously these are all fictional, but some depicted knights slaying griffins because you’re not going to beef up your legend by showing your butt getting kicked by an eagle-lion. But there was one image of a griffin carrying a knight and its horse in its talons to feed the two to its baby griffins. Golden Griffins get the win.
#21 Marshall Thundering Herd over #4 Penn State Nittany Lions - Per Mascot Madness rules we are talking about one mountain lion verses an entire herd of buffalo.
#6 Hofstra Pride over #3 Rutgers Scarlet Knights - Pride of lions versus a single knight; one wearing scarlet which is not the most stealthy color.
#26 LIU Sharks over #15 UMass Minutemen - I know what you’re thinking: the minutemen has a gun. But a Revolutionary War-era musket would not shoot well into the water and take a heck of a long time to reload. Suddenly we’re talking man versus shark and shark wins.