I have a new office in our home and one of the things I am enjoying is decorating the space. I have placed books, Lego sets, and Funko Pops on the shelves. My wall has photos of family, places that I have traveled, artwork my siblings have given me, diplomas, etc. Across from my desk on the wall, hangs a cross that we got from a church in Reykjavik and a small colorfully-painted tile depicting Assisi. On the floor beneath them is the one item in here that I haven’t yet put up: my certificate of ordination.
I was ordained as a minister ten years ago today. It was a step with which I struggled for awhile. My Baptist roots fostered in me a firm belief in the priesthood of all believers. If you say that you are a follower of Jesus, then you are a minister. So the hierarchy implied by being called “Reverend” made me feel a little uncomfortable. I did not use the title for myself often unless I was writing my Congressperson. Despite these qualms, I did ultimately pursue ordination. I am glad that I did. I am just not totally sure what to make of it now.
I don’t serve as a vocational minister anymore; not in a church, not as a chaplain, not in some sort of parachurch organization. I am an Administrative Assistant in a hospital Spiritual Care department. In fact, I haven’t even attended a church service in maybe a year and a half save an Ash Wednesday service that I snuck off to at the beginning of Lent. I did officiate a wedding in a church over the summer; an experience that I loved and was very meaningful for me. But I don’t really know what to do about that ordination certificate. Or church.
A month or so ago, I was talking on the phone with Peter who was one of my educators during my chaplain residency. Knowing some of my history, he asked where my family and I were with church. I told him that we weren’t going anywhere presently. More than that I said that I struggled with the simultaneous feelings of “This is all bullshit” and “This is a true and real thing that means so much to me.” He affirmed that these feelings were not unusual and feels like that himself at times.
When I say “This is all bullshit,” I am not talking about Jesus or faith or anything like that. Faith is still a constant presence in my life. It actually might be easier if it were not. I am writing this after I did my regular practice in which I prayed the Divine Office and read several psalms. I still try to write devotionals for my sons. There are days in which I try to make it through my cubicle job by pretending that I am a monk; a monk who is married and deeply nerdy but a person who is trying to follow a spiritual order nonetheless.
I don’t think that Jesus is bullshit. But I often think that our attempts to be Christlike are. That’s baggage from years in a denomination where women were excluded from the pulpit and many other people were excluded outright. And from bearing a lifetime of witness to a widespread assumption that Jesus is aligned with bomb-dropping, misogynistic, xenophobic billionaires. And from seeing the jagged-edged shortcomings of religious leaders from faraway and up close. And it is all compounded by my own deep hurts experienced in a place that is supposed to be a haven.
I know in my head that those experiences are not the totality of the story. I know that imperfection is built into the system; only needing to look inside myself to know how we can royally screw up trying to follow Jesus. I know that there are good communities of faith out there who are trying their best. But knowing that and getting to experience that are two different things. And I don’t know if we just haven’t found the right place but it feels like such a crapshoot. It makes me wonder if I am just unlucky or if there is something wrong with me.
I understand that a person is not their job, but I was also pretty inundated with ideas of calling, vocation, and letting your life speak throughout college and seminary. So where do you go when you are not doing what you thought you were meant to do? And when the place you thought you belonged doesn’t feel like home?
The Call to Worship at my ordination service was “Helplessness Blues” by Fleet Foxes, sung by my sister and a friend. Depending on the day, the lyrics “What’s my name? What’s my station?” are either a taunt or a prayerful question. So to plant myself in the latter, I take a deep breath and try to remember that none of this is tidy. Life does not work out as easily as we think it should. Life, as my parents regularly reminded me as a child, is not fair. And God is still with us—will always be with us—in the mess.
I am a minister in small and ordinary but nevertheless important ways. And I believe you are too. I pray that all of us can find somewhere we belong.
While I was in the middle of writing this, my sixteen year old came into the office. He admired the autographed Superman print that is on the wall and the model of a Disney monorail on one of my shelves. Then he looked at the ordination certificate on the floor and asked, “Where are you going to put that?” So I guess I need to hang that certificate up on the wall. And we’ll take all of these questions, disappointments, fears, and hopes one day at a time.
I have a new office in our home and one of the things I am enjoying is decorating the space. I have placed books, Lego sets, and Funko Pops on the shelves. My wall has photos of family, places that I have traveled, artwork my siblings have given me, diplomas, etc. Across from my desk on the wall, hangs a cross that we got from a church in Reykjavik and a small colorfully-painted tile depicting Assisi. On the floor beneath them is the one item in here that I haven’t yet put up: my certificate of ordination.
I was ordained as a minister ten years ago today. It was a step with which I struggled for awhile. My Baptist roots fostered in me a firm belief in the priesthood of all believers. If you say that you are a follower of Jesus, then you are a minister. So the hierarchy implied by being called “Reverend” made me feel a little uncomfortable. I did not use the title for myself often unless I was writing my Congressperson. Despite these qualms, I did ultimately pursue ordination. I am glad that I did. I am just not totally sure what to make of it now.
I don’t serve as a vocational minister anymore; not in a church, not as a chaplain, not in some sort of parachurch organization. I am an Administrative Assistant in a hospital Spiritual Care department. In fact, I haven’t even attended a church service in maybe a year and a half save an Ash Wednesday service that I snuck off to at the beginning of Lent. I did officiate a wedding in a church over the summer; an experience that I loved and was very meaningful for me. But I don’t really know what to do about that ordination certificate. Or church.