Here is what I wish my friends in the evangelical church would believe about me (for that's the only person I can speak of) as someone who has gone outside the doors of that brand of Christianity: It was never about leaving Christ.
When I finally had the guts to say that Black Lives Matter, support rights for LGBTQ+ individuals, criticize the ways American nationalism compromises the church, and push back against biblical inerrancy, I wasn't trying to leave something. I was trying to move closer to Christ.
I want to follow Jesus the best I can. Sometimes I am awful at it. I get things wrong. But to paraphrase a song: I want to be a Christian in my heart, my head, my actions. So very badly. And where I am is where the journey has taken me thus far.
I have not strayed. I have not left the church (in fact I work as a minister in a local congregation). I have not capitulated to culture or been brainwashed by the media. I have thought and fought and prayed and studied. Though it looks different I probably cling to God more now.
The church in this country has a reckoning upon it. And I'm not saying that the Christian faith in this country should look like mine. That's just an inverse of the fundamentalism that put a lot of us out in the cold. But we've got to find a better way forward. And the best way we can find a better way forward is if we realize that our little patch of land is not the whole great wide country of Christianity.
You've got to trust me when I say that I am trying to follow Christ in good faith. You've got to listen when I say my gay friend is following Jesus. You've got to not throw up your defenses when I say that responding "All Lives Matter" is hurtful. I need you to hear me when I say that maybe we've made an idol out of the Bible. When I say all of this, I need you to trust that I'm not trying to destroy something. I'm not trying to start a fight. I'm trying to follow Christ the best I can.
This isn't to say that you aren't trying to follow Jesus if you disagree with me. But I need my evangelical brothers & sisters to know that many of us out here never left the church, never left the faith. We're out here because that is where we honestly believe God has called us.
I believe that most of us experience an internal tug-of-war between the past and the future. In The Screwtape Letters, C.S. Lewis’ titular demon supervisor advises his underling Wormwood that one of best ways to keep a human from doing good is to keep them ping-ponging between those two times that are not the present. One keeps trying to recapture or reach towards moments that are mist. It can keep a person from doing something.
The quote above resonates with me because it harnesses the past and unfinished future into a catalyst that animates our present. We remember the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus because it means something today and compels us to presently work for the Good that is already here, but also not yet. We remember the hope and pain of the past to do something that help us take some sort of step each and every day. We realize that the hope which exists within the gospel story is not yet fully realized. Many people are still being left behind and forgotten. The realization, as the theologian Metz states, puts pressure and questions on the present.