Mary and Martha Go to Couple's Therapy
Luke 10:38-42
Gospel Reading for the Ninth Sunday after Pentecost (Year C)
(Mary and Martha sit in an office on a couch. Martha has her arms folded in defiance.)
Martha: Couple's therapy? Really?
Mary: We need to talk this out and I figured counseling would help us some...
Martha: It's couple's therapy, Mary. We are not a couple!
Mary: We're a couple of sisters.
Martha: Of all the stupid...
Mary: What was I supposed to do? Do you realize how many sermons have set us up as diametrically opposed? It's tearing us apart. We've been pitted against each other.
Martha: Yeah and they think you're the good one! (In a whiny voice) "Be a Mary in a Martha world." It's like I'm the epitome of all that's wrong with this planet. It's not like I was robbing poor people blind. I was making Jesus a meal for Pete's sake!
(Therapist enters)
Therapist: How appropriate. I was just in session with Peter and his brother Andrew.
Mary: See? It's not just for couple couples.
Therapist: My apologies for being late. I can't really comment, but let's just say it would be difficult having an impulsive, occasionally loud mouthed older brother who was told he was the foundation of the church.
Mary: We understand. I'm Mary.
Therapist: Which makes you Martha?
Martha: Glad to see you earned that degree hung on your wall.
Mary: Forgive my sister. She has a bit of a chip on her shoulder.
Therapist: Well that's why we're here. I am going to let you two do most of the talking. I may ask a question here or there, but I don't want you to feel like I'm steering the ship. Usually the couple can best find their way forward with minimal input on my part.
Martha: We're not a...
Therapist: You are two people with a close relationship. In this room, you're a couple.
Martha: Fine. So who's going to go first?
Therapist: Your choice. You can both go.
Mary: All of this started when Jesus was in our town and Martha invited him to stay at our house, which was very kind of her.
Therapist: That was kind of you to compliment her like that, Mary.
Martha: I swear to my friend, if you take her side...
Therapist: I'm not taking sides. Your sister paid you a compliment. She said you were kind.
Martha: You're right. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mary.
Mary: It was kind.
Therapist: What happened next?
Martha: I was preparing dinner, which I'd like to point out is a biblically mandated thing that you're supposed to do for someone bringing the good news.
Mary: That's true. It's literally in the same chapter as our story. "Remain in this house, eating and drinking whatever they set in front of you."
Martha: So it's not like I was intentionally trying to be rude to Jesus, but...
Therapist: But what?
Martha: I was doing all the prep work and I was kind of ticked off at Mary because she was just sitting in the other room talking with the teacher.
Therapist: How did that make you feel?
Martha: Frustrated. A little angry. I wanted to be in there too. And I was upset she wasn't helping me.
Therapist: Mary, what's your response?
Mary: I get that. I really do. But...I mean, it was Jesus. Wild horses couldn't pull me away, much less prepping a casserole.
Martha: I get that too.
Therapist: Continue with the story.
Martha: So I was trying to get her attention. I banged pots and pans loudly.
Mary: One time she called out, "Sorry it's taking me, by myself, such a long, long time, Jesus." Subtlety is not her strong suit.
Martha: Eventually I had enough. I stormed in and demanded that Jesus tell Martha to help me.
Mary: That was a pretty big gun to pull out. Messiah, make my sister do household chores.
Therapist: How did Jesus respond?
Martha: He told me that I was distracted by many things and that one thing was missing, which my sister chose. He called it the better part.
Therapist: So he was saying that what Mary was doing was better?
Mary: Maybe. Kind of. I'm not totally sure. It's kind of fuzzy. Translating from Greek and all that. But can I say something?
Therapist: Of course.
Mary: I don't think he was condemning my sister. Maybe setting her straight for trying to force him to force me to work. But I think he was appreciative of what Martha was doing.
Martha: You do?
Mary: Yeah, like you said, you were doing what you were supposed to as a host. The work is one side of things and the devotion is the other side. He didn't want you to take away that time of devotion from me. So I don't think he was condemning work as much as he was reminding you that time spent with him was important too.
Therapist: Martha?
Martha: So you're saying it's not so much "Be a Mary in a Martha world," but "Be a Mary and Martha in the world"?
Mary: Maybe. I mean at this point I'm the figment of a 21st century blogger's imagination infused with a commentary he read. But yeah, I think that both sides are important. We're not enemies or opposite poles. We're sisters under the same house.
Martha: We are. We go together. And that means a lot coming from you. You're right, I have had a chip on my shoulder about all of this.
Mary: And I certainly don't think our whole story means that women are supposed to be quietly listening in church while the men do everything.
Martha: Oh, don't even get me started on that.
Therapist: I hate to do this because I think we are making some incredible progress, but I have another session with Paul and Barnabas coming up. Same time next week?
Martha: Yeah. Thanks Doc.
Mary: You want to get some dinner? My treat.
Martha: You know this doesn't make up for...
Mary: Yeah, yeah.
Martha: Thanks sis.
Mary: No problem.
(End)

I believe that most of us experience an internal tug-of-war between the past and the future. In The Screwtape Letters, C.S. Lewis’ titular demon supervisor advises his underling Wormwood that one of best ways to keep a human from doing good is to keep them ping-ponging between those two times that are not the present. One keeps trying to recapture or reach towards moments that are mist. It can keep a person from doing something.
The quote above resonates with me because it harnesses the past and unfinished future into a catalyst that animates our present. We remember the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus because it means something today and compels us to presently work for the Good that is already here, but also not yet. We remember the hope and pain of the past to do something that help us take some sort of step each and every day. We realize that the hope which exists within the gospel story is not yet fully realized. Many people are still being left behind and forgotten. The realization, as the theologian Metz states, puts pressure and questions on the present.